Skip to content
INDEX LIVE from 18 public venues indexed How we measure →

Methodology

Every number on Warro Intel is defined here, in plain language, with the exact formula. If a number cannot be defined, it is not shown — a missing metric reads “collecting data”, never a guess.

What we index — and what we never do

Warro Intel indexes public Telegram channels only. A channel enters the index only if it has a public username, resolves as a broadcast channel, and its history is readable without joining. Public status is re-checked on every crawl pass; a channel that goes private or is deleted is purged from public results within 24 hours.

We never index private chats, private groups, mcrimson lists, phone numbers, email addresses, or documents. Message text is redacted at serve time — phone numbers, identity numbers and email addresses are stripped before anything is shown. Media files are not downloaded; only text and metadata are stored.

Channels flagged as adult (18+) at ingest are excluded from the public index entirely: not listed, not searchable, not in rankings or sitemaps.

Combined score

The combined score is the default sort order for search and catalog pages. It rewards size, activity, citations and reach — on a logarithmic scale, so a channel with ten times the subscribers does not score ten times higher. Throughout this page, lg means log10.

score = lg(1 + subscribers)
      + activity
      + lg(1 + venues citing in 30d)
      + 0.6 · lg(1 + avg reach)
      + 0.3 if verified

For channels, activity = 0.6 · lg(1 + posts in 30d). (Groups use writers instead of posts when group indexing arrives; V1 is channels-only, so the group term does not apply yet.)

The score has no fixed ceiling and no hidden weighting. Two channels with the same inputs always get the same score.

Engagement rate (ER)

ER measures how much of a channel's audience actually sees its posts.

ER = avg reach ÷ subscribers × 100%

An ER above 100% is possible and normal: posts can be viewed by non-subscribers through forwards and shares.

Average reach

Average reach is the mean view count of a channel's recent posts. Views keep growing after a post is published, so each post's view count is refreshed once, 24–48 hours after posting, and then frozen. This keeps reach comparable between a post from yesterday and a post from last week.

Activity: posts, writers, citations

  • Posts (30d) — public posts published in the last 30 days.
  • Writers (30d) — a group metric (not shown for channels): the count of distinct authors in the last 30 days, counted as a true distinct count, never by adding up daily counts.
  • Citations (30d) — how many other indexed venues linked to or forwarded from this channel in the last 30 days. A citation counts once per citing venue, however many times it linked.

Authenticity

The authenticity score starts at 100 and subtracts penalties for warning signs — for example a sudden subscriber spike, or engagement far below peer channels of the same category and size band. It is a warning-signs score, not a verdict: a low score means “look closer”, never “this channel is fake”.

The score is shown only when there is enough history to judge: at least 14 days in the index and at least 100 subscribers. Below that, the page reads “collecting data”.

Growth and collecting states

Growth is measured from daily subscriber snapshots. The 7-day change is today's count minus the count 7 days ago; the growth chart needs at least 7 days of snapshots before it is drawn. Until then, the venue page shows a “collecting data” state — we never estimate, interpolate or backfill a growth line.

A missing stat is shown as “—” or “collecting data”, never as zero. Zero is a measurement; no data is no data.

Rankings and eligibility

Rankings list the top 100 channels per list. Rate-based lists (engagement, fastest growing) require at least 1,000 subscribers, so a tiny channel cannot top a list on a percentage quirk. The “fastest growing” list ranks by 7-day growth percentage and requires a measured 7-day change; while the index is younger than a week, 1-day growth stands in so the list is not empty.

Rankings are recomputed several times a day from the latest stats snapshot, and every ranking page states the live index coverage it was computed from.

Freshness and caching

Stats are recomputed several times a day; each venue page shows the exact time its numbers were computed (“data as of …”). Active channels are crawled more often than quiet ones. Cached pages are served for up to 12 hours for venue pages, 1 hour for catalog and ranking pages, and 5 minutes for search results — a cached number is a snapshot, never presented as live.

Categories

The catalog has 18 categories and around 60 subcategories. A channel is assigned to one category from its public title and description, with manual review of the largest channels. Categories with no indexed channels yet are shown with a zero count rather than hidden.

If a formula on this page ever changes, this page changes with it — the methodology is part of the product, not marketing copy.